Apple vs US antitrust case sees more discovery roadblocks


The DOJ spent years threatening to bring antitrust charges against Apple, and now that it finally has, the US government seems incapable of participating in its own case.

The United States Department of Justice brought antitrust claims against Apple in June 2024. After a year of appeals, the case was pushed into going forward.

In the months since, things have been at a standstill as no one seems ready to budge on discovery requests. The DOJ complained of Apple refusing document requests in September, then Apple complained similarly about Samsung in April, and now a joint filing viewed by AppleInsider shows more pointing fingers.

In this instance, it’s Apple accusing the United States government and the 14 agencies being subpoenaed of halting the case.

From the filing:

The United States, having brought this action, cannot avoid its discovery obligations by putting Apple through an endless procedural runaround. The parties have discussed these issues repeatedly over the past year, but those efforts have not resulted in a resolution. Apple is entitled to obtain relevant, narrowly targeted materials from a small subset of the United States’ own agencies, and Apple therefore respectfully requests that the Court order the United States to produce the materials requested in Apple’s final compromise proposal, attached as Appendix A.

The DOJ’s arguments can be whittled down to “it’s too hard to provide these documents that have little relevance anyway.” It’s not a very good argument when Apple’s requests appear relevant.

If the United States is suing Apple on antitrust grounds, then how the agencies view Apple within the US government has some relevance. They choose iPhones for government use for a reason, and Apple believes, rightly, that those reasons would contradict the grounds of the antitrust case.

Round and round we go

I’m not a lawyer, but I would wager that the US government’s refusal here is an obvious attempt to avoid looking foolish. The case is very thin as it is, and federal agencies rely on Apple’s technology because of its closed and secure nature.

As a reminder, here’s Apple’s rebuttal against the five claims made by the DOJ:

  • DOJ says Apple stifles the success of “super apps,” despite the fact that Apple’s rules allow and support such apps, and indeed a multitude of “super apps” exist on the App Store today
  • DOJ says Apple blocks cloud streaming games, even though Apple allows streaming-games both over the web and in the App Store where they can stream games directly to users
  • DOJ says Apple degrades third-party messaging apps, even though they are widely available and enormously popular on iPhone already
  • DOJ says Apple limits the functionality of third-party smartwatches, even though they can effectively pair with iPhone, share data to and from the iPhone via a companion app, and take advantage of certain functionalities Apple has developed which are expanding over time
  • DOJ says Apple withholds access to iPhone hardware necessary for third-party digital wallets to use tap-to-pay technology, however, Apple developed and provides a mechanism that protects user

These were barely credible claims when they were first made by the DOJ in 2024, but they’re less so today. Even the smartwatch one has changed with iOS 26.3 thanks to notification forwarding to third-party smartwatches.

If this becomes a debate of “yeah, Apple does these things but not in a way we like,” I doubt it’ll make it very far. However, since everyone involved is dragging their feet through discovery, including Apple, Samsung, and now the US government, I have no doubt we’ll be talking about this case for years to come.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get our latest articles delivered straight to your inbox. No spam, we promise.

Recent Reviews


Three-row family SUVs are expected to do everything; carry passengers comfortably, handle long road trips, keep running costs manageable, and remain dependable for years. Finding one that checks every box without becoming too expensive can be difficult, especially when fuel economy starts to matter as much as space. One hybrid Toyota stands out by delivering all of those priorities in a single package.

This three-row SUV combines the practicality families need with the efficiency advantages of hybrid power. It offers spacious seating, strong everyday comfort, and the kind of long-term reliability Toyota is known for, while using significantly less fuel than many traditional V-6 rivals in the same segment.

For buyers balancing family needs with ownership costs, that combination makes a major difference. It proves that a large SUV doesn’t have to be expensive to run or stressful to own, just thoughtfully engineered around what families actually need most.

In order to give you the most up-to-date and accurate information possible, the data used to compile this article was sourced from various manufacturer websites, including the EPA, CarEdge, and J.D. Power.

Mercedes-Benz 2027 C-Class Electric


Mercedes’ 2027 electric C-Class is its sportiest version yet—EV or not

You can also expect long range and ample in-cabin tech.

The 2026 Toyota Grand Highlander Hybrid is affordable and built to last

Dependability is a big priority here

If you’re looking for a family SUV that is spacious, light on gas, and will last you a long time with few issues, then the Grand Highlander Hybrid feels like a no-brainer. It is slightly pricier than some of its direct rivals, but Toyota’s experience in developing hybrid means that you can rest peacefully knowing that this three-row SUV should last you years without any problem.

2026 Toyota Grand Highlander Hybrid trims and pricing

Model

Starting MSRP

LE

$45,210

XLE

$46,380

Limited

$52,710

Nightshade Edition

$53,690

Platinum

$59,775

Compared to other hybrid three-row SUVs, the Grand Highlander is priced pretty well. While there are some more affordable options, like the Hyundai Palisade and Santa Fe, it undercuts rivals like the Kia Telluride and the Mazda CX-90. This middle of the pack pricing is about on-par for Toyota.

Of the above trims, we think that opting for the XLE gets you the best bang for your buck. It comes with all the features you’d want in a family hauler, such as a power-operated liftgate, a spattering of USB-C ports throughout the cabin, heated front seats, faux-leather upholstery, and a very comprehensive suite of driver aids.

Warranties, maintenance, and reliability

  • Reliability score: 82/100 (J.D. Power)
  • Limited warranty: 3 years or 36,000 miles
  • Powertrain warranty: 5 years or 60,000 miles
  • Complimentary maintenance: 2 years or 24,000 miles
  • Average ten-year maintenance costs: $6,299 (CarEdge)

Toyota offers a pretty standard warranty package to back up their reputation for reliability. While the Grand Highlander is technically a newer model, it is essentially just a long wheelbase version of the regular Highlander, meaning its mechanical components have proven themselves to be dependable.

Your first two years or scheduled maintenance visits are free with your purchase of a Grand Highlander. After that point, maintenance is reasonably affordable. CarEdge estimates that the average SUV would cost you $1,867 more to maintain over ten years than the Grand Highlander.

A silver Lexus GX 460 parked on a street alongside a sidewalk in a city.


Forget Mercedes—this Lexus SUV is the smarter luxury buy

Mercedes may lead luxury, but this Lexus SUV delivers the same upscale feel with way less ownership stress.

There is plenty of space in all three rows of the Grand Highlander Hybrid

Its cabin is simple but exceptionally practical

While the cabins of Toyota’s vehicles are usually a little pedestrian, there is something to be said about how versatile they are, as well as how easy they are to live with. The Grand Highlander definitely follows this trend. While it lacks the flair that some of its rivals offer, it delivers three rows of spacious seating, tons of modern tech, and loads of storage space.

Interior dimensions and comfort

Front row headroom

41.5 inches

Front row legroom

41.7 inches

Second row headroom

40.2 inches

Second row legroom

39.5 inches

Third row headroom

37.2 inches

Third row legroom

33.5 inches

Cargo capacity (behind third row)

20.6 cubic feet

The ‘Grand’ in Grand Highlander refers to the fact that it is quite a bit bigger than the traditional Highlander, with much more room on the inside. While the third row is still best suited for the kids, you could definitely fit a pair of adults back there at a push. We’re also really impressed with how much cargo space there is behind the third row.

The cabin layout of the Grand Highlander is very neat. Everything is easy to find and there are a ton of storage compartments scattered throughout. Its design won’t blow you away, but you’ll be pleased with just how intuitive all the controls are. The most affordable trims focus on the essentials, but top trims can come with some pretty plush features, including genuine leather upholstery, heated and ventilated front seats, and captain’s chairs in the second row.

Amazon Basics Trunk Organizer

Material

Oxford

Organizer Dimensions

21″L x 14.6″W x 10.3″H

Special Feature

Foldable

This 13.5-gallon trunk organizer features compartments to organize and store groceries, sports equipment, emergency supplies, and other daily essentials.


Infotainment and technology

Every Grand Highlander comes equipped with a 12.3-inch infotainment screen mounted to the top of the dashboard. Lower trim levels come with a hybrid gauge cluster that includes a seven-inch display in the middle, but from the Limited up you get a fully digital 12.3-inch unit instead.

As we already mentioned, there are a number of USB-C ports throughout the cabin, so that the whole family can charge their devices. A wireless charging pad is also included. Three-zone automatic climate control and wireless smartphone mirroring are standard on every trim level. Top trims also offer some better tech, including a heads-up display and an 11-speaker JBL sound system.

Hauling the family doesn’t have to mean spending a ton on gas

The Grand Highlander hybrid is impressively thrifty

Full view of a black 2025 Toyota Grand Highlander driving. Credit: Toyota

Toyota’s ideology of function over form definitely translates into how they tune the performance of their cars. The Grand Highlander Hybrid may not be the most interesting SUV from behind the wheel, but its fuel-sipping powertrain and plush ride means that it will save you money in the long run and keep the family happy.

Grand Highlander Hybrid performance and efficiency

Model

Hybrid

Hybrid MAX

Engine

2.5-liter naturally aspirated inline-four

2.4-liter turbocharged inline-four

Transmission

CVT

6-speed automatic

Horsepower

245 HP

362 HP

Torque

288 LB-FT

400 LB-FT

Driveline

FWD or AWD

AWD

0-60 MPH

7.8 seconds

5.6 seconds

The Grand Highlander Hybrid comes in two different forms. Most models feature a naturally aspirated inline-four under the hood. The Platinum comes exclusively with the Hybrid MAX setup, though, with the Limited offering a choice of either. The standard hybrid powertrain better suits the Grand Highlander in our mind, with the Hybrid MAX’s quick acceleration clashing with the SUV’s laid-back personality, especially because it takes it toll when it comes to efficiency.

As is the case with a lot of Toyota’s mainstream models, the Grand Highlander lacks excitement, even accounting for the Hybrid MAX’s quick acceleration. Steering is exceptionally light and vague, and the suspension is clearly set up for comfort. This isn’t a bad thing in our eyes, though, as the mission of the Japanese SUV is to get your family from A to B. This is where its comfortable ride quality really shines through.

Fuel economy

Model

City

Highway

Combined

Hybrid FWD

37 MPG

34 MPG

36 MPG

Hybrid AWD

36 MPG

32 MPG

34 MPG

Hybrid MAX AWD

26 MPG

27 MPG

27 MPG


There are few SUVs as well-suited to family life

Toyota skips the flash and the gimmicks that a lot of other brands have leaned into in the last couple of years. They focus instead on proven technology and long-term dependability. If you’re buying a family vehicle, that should be high up on your list of priorities. Any parent will tell you that they’d take simple functionality over anything, which is what makes the Grand Highlander Hybrid such a solid choice in this segment.



Source link