I let ChatGPT and Claude build my Spotify playlists, and this one was the clear winner


Spotify recently released a new feature that is not surprising, given its recent string of updates, but it is still something overdue since last year. With the Spotify-Claude integration, Spotify may be setting up for a better overall listening and discovery experience for users.

But how does this brand-new integration compare against Spotify’s integration with ChatGPT? I tested them both by creating playlists with the same prompts, and there was a clear winner. Here is all you need to know.

The new Spotify-Claude integration

Who can use it?

Spotify announced its Claude integration in mid-April, adding to its list of AI-powered music discovery features. This allows you to connect Spotify with Claude and get personalized music and podcast recommendations based on your Spotify listening history and taste profile. According to Spotify, Claude’s recommendations come from Spotify’s personalization technology and “deep catalog expertise.”

The Claude integration comes months after the Spotify-ChatGPT integration, which also allows for music discovery and playlist creation.

The new Spotify-Claude integration is available for both Free and Premium Spotify users, with Premium users getting the added advantage of describing a vibe or mood to get a playlist tailored to their prompt. Currently, the integration is available worldwide, for Free, Pro, and Max Claude users on the web, mobile (iOS and Android), and desktop, who have an existing Spotify account they can connect to.

How to use it

To begin using Spotify in Claude, sign into your Claude account and open a new chat. Then type a prompt addressing Spotify (for example, “Spotify, can you recommend me some upbeat songs for my morning workout?”). Claude will prompt you to allow search on Spotify. Once you accept that, you will get preview recommendations. From here, click on “Link your Spotify account” to get the full experience. Follow the instructions to connect Spotify to Claude.

Before you sign in to your Spotify account, you will also be prompted to connect to Spotify as a connector to Claude. When you click “Connect,” you will simply connect Spotify to Claude in the chat, then use it to create playlists and find new music.

If you are a Spotify Premium user, you can even ask Claude the “vibe or mood” you’re in, and it will create a playlist to match it.

From here, you can click on any playlist or recommendation that Claude has generated for you, which will open it on Spotify for easy listening.

As for Spotify Connect, this part of the integration might be rolled out in phases or in due time because my Claude does not support it as of early May. But this feature should allow you to control playback from within Claude, given that the AI chatbot can access your “Currently Playing” to fetch more details about what you are listening to.

Does Claude beat ChatGPT?

How will Spotify’s integration with Claude evolve?

When I saw the announcement of this integration, I knew I would immediately want to compare how Spotify works with Claude versus how it works with its earlier integration with ChatGPT. What sets the Claude integration apart from ChatGPT — apart from subjective experience — is Spotify Connect support, which should allow users to control playback within the chat.

As for the main feature, playlist creation, I tested the same prompt with both Claude and ChatGPT. The prompt I used was very specific to my needs — “Spotify, make me a playlist with dark academia vibes that I can listen to when I’m reading the book ‘Babel’ by R.F. Kuang.” Both playlists were ready in seconds, available to be added on Spotify directly, and featured 30 songs (Claude’s playlist was about half an hour longer because of its picks).

ChatGPT’s picks felt familiar, with seven out of the thirty songs being in my Liked Songs, and a few that I listen to on Smart Shuffle but never added to my library.

On the other hand, Claude’s playlist was new, with many classical music suggestions that I ended up enjoying. More importantly, when I listened to both playlists while reading the book, I found Claude’s playlist was much more accurate to my prompt (meeting the “dark academia” vibe with its curation), while ChatGPT missed the mark on the occasion.​​​​​​​

I created two more different playlists with specific prompts that I tried out later, and a clear winner emerged: Claude’s playlist was more loyal to the details of my prompt and helped me discover new, obscure music that rarely shows up on my Smart Shuffle or discovery radar. And given that this was the result weeks after launch, it will be interesting to watch how the Claude-Spotify integration evolves.

ChatGPT logo on a transparent background

What’s included?

Unlimited conversations, faster response speed, priority access, and more

Brand

ChatGPT


My problem with Spotify’s AI integration features

Audio is still the primary issue

While it’s exciting to see Spotify bring new integrations like these, I am more interested in seeing the audio streaming platform improve its existing AI-powered features. For instance, the AI DJ feature has gotten some upgrades since launch (like better language capabilities, text requests, etc.), but this is a Spotify feature that has some insane potential. Improvements like better personalization features, remix features, more voice options, etc., can go a long way.

Plus, unless Spotify commits to bringing more features to such AI chatbot integrations, the Claude and ChatGPT integrations are primarily discoverability features that users may simply prefer to do through Spotify. The AI Playlist, for instance, creates playlists based on moods and prompts in seconds for you within the app, making these new integrations feel a little redundant. And the addition of the new feature, Prompted Playlist, adds to the competition.


​​​​​​​Spotify’s future with Claude

I am excited to see what the Claude-Spotify integration can bring for users via Spotify Connect and more upgrades. Despite my skepticism about these integrations, I’m looking forward to how Spotify might adapt these features into the larger listening experience.

Spotify Logo on transparent background

Subscription with ads

No ads on any paid plan

Price

Starting at $12.99/month, or $6.99/month for students

Spotify is a pioneer in music streaming. It features a vast library, impressive bitrate, curated and custom playlists, as well as offline streaming. Spotify is available for free and for a monthly or annual fee.




Source link

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get our latest articles delivered straight to your inbox. No spam, we promise.

Recent Reviews


What streaming platform do you think of when you hear the term “comfort shows?” There are plenty of great comfort shows over on Netflix, or maybe available with an HBO Max subscription. But for me, I always think of Peacock.

With a Peacock subscription, there are so many options for classic comfort shows that will no doubt make your day—and provide you with that comfy need that we all so desperately crave. Here are seven that you must check out.

The Office

A classic comedy

Dwight in The Office. Credit: NBC

I mean, you knew it was going to be on here, don’t lie.​​​​​​​

The Office was a nine-season sitcom that took the world by storm. Starring Steve Carell as Michael Scott, this iconic workplace comedy follows the professional and personal lives of workers at a paper company in Scranton, Pennsylvania.

I think The Office is a show that defines the word “comfort.” Anytime I ask people what they usually put on in the background, The Office is always the first choice because it’s easy to follow, has characters you want to root for, and is so freaking funny (even if some of those jokes have not aged well all these years later). It’s certainly worth a shot

Parks And Recreation

Amy Poehler is the best

Amy Poehler in Parks and Recreation speaking to a camera Credit: NBC

Another great comfort show that also happens to come from the same developer of the U.S. version of The Office (the wonderful Greg Daniels), Parks and Recreation is a sitcom mainly about Leslie Knope, a mid-level bureaucrat who is trying to improve her home in the fictional town of Pawnee, Indiana, in the Parks and Recreation department.

The series is extremely well-received and has some huge stars attached, including Amy Poehler, Aziz Ansari, Nick Offerman, Adam Scott, Chris Pratt, Aubrey Plaza, and more. With seven seasons and one hundred and twenty-six episodes, you’re in for a long binge.​​​​​​​

Brooklyn Nine-Nine

The laughs go on and on

b99.jpg
Andy dressed asAndy Samberg as Jake Peralta with his arm around Eva Longoria as Sophia Perez in Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Brooklyn Nine-Nine is one of those shows that I think everyone has seen at least one episode of, just because it’s so funny. The main premise of the series follows the lives of police officers, detectives, and others in a fictional police precinct in New York, specifically in Brooklyn.

This series was a hit for NBC, and while it did move to another streaming platform towards the end of its run, it is a beloved comedy perfect for a weekend of comfy watching. Not only that, but the stars—Andy Samberg, Terry Crews, and more—have some of the best chemistry out there and will, no doubt, make you laugh out loud.

Everybody Loves Raymond

Who doesn’t love an Italian Long Island-er?

Ray Romano in Everybody Loves Raymond Credit: CBS

You better believe I put Everybody Loves Raymond on here—because everyone loves it!

This late 1990s-early 2000s sitcom stars Ray Romano as Ray Barone, an Italian-American who lives on Long Island and has made it as a successful sports writer. It tells the story of his family and how he deals with the drama, juggling his wife, his neighbors, and more.​​​​​​​


The Simpsons on Disney+ on a 4K TV in a green living room.


The 5 Most Popular Comfort Shows and Where to Stream Them

Switch on these shows when you want to switch off.

I genuinely cannot think of another television show I have seen more often over the last couple of decades than this, and the number of reruns is astronomical. With nine seasons, Everybody Loves Raymond is the type of binge you don’t want to miss.​​​​​​​

Modern Family

A series anyone can relate to

Claire and Phil Dunphy in Modern Family Credit: ABC

Now this is my kind of comfort show. Modern Family—and all eleven of its seasons—is available to stream on Peacock.

This groundbreaking sitcom tells the stories of three diverse families in the suburbs of Los Angeles and how their lives intersect. But it’s so much more than that. The comedy is hysterical, and yet each episode finds a new way to tug at your heartstrings.

Not only that, but it’s also just a genuinely relatable show for modern-day parents, and I’m not just saying that because of the name. It touches on both funny topics and social issues, making it a really well-done series. There’s a reason why there were so many Emmys thrown at this series.

That ‘70s Show

So much smoke—and friends!

Topher Grace on That '70s Show. Credit: Fox

For some reason, That ‘70s Show was the series I was obsessed with as a kid. And honestly, it’s a vibe, even now. The series mainly follows six teenagers in Wisconsin between 1976 and 1979 as they come of age, experience growing pains, and learn to come into their own while also smoking the devil’s lettuce, if you know what I mean.

On a real note, That ‘70s Show is a hilarious series with great performances from Topher Grace, Mila Kunis, Ashton Kutcher, Wilmer Valderrama, and so many more. This series has been with me on my good days and bad, and while its little successor, That ‘90s Show, on Netflix is a fun one, nothing compares to the original. You’re missing out if haven’t had the chance to sit down and watch the whole show.

Saturday Night Live

Laughs and more

Bill Hader and Ben Affleck in Saturday Night Live Credit: NBC

OK, so hear me out.

I know, when it comes to comfort shows, we honestly do think sitcoms are cute, but I think Saturday Night Live falls into that category. Why? Because it’s one of those shows that you can put on in the background and just chill.

It’s not something that’s heavily serialized or has any real plot to follow. It’s just funny sketches and enjoyable music performances. That’s it. And with the number of seasons that are available to watch on Peacock, you can’t really get better than this.


Peacock is such a great subscription service, and honestly, it just makes me want to rewatch each of these awesome shows. What are you looking forward to watching on a comfy weekend?

peacock thumbnail

Subscription with ads

Yes, $8/month

Simultaneous streams

3




Source link