Elementary OS vs. Linux Mint: I compared my once favorite distro to the Windows alternative


Mint vs Elementary

Linux Mint and Elementary

Follow ZDNET: Add us as a preferred source on Google.


ZDNET’s key takeaways

  • Both elementary OS and Linux Mint are great for new users.
  • Each distribution appeals to a different type of user.
  • You can install and use both for free.

Linux has more different distributions than a puzzle has pieces. They number in the thousands, and range from the very easy to the incredibly complicated.

Clearly, if you’re new to Linux, you’re going to want to start with something that can painlessly introduce you to the open-source operating system. Every Linux user has an opinion on which distribution is best suited for new users, but I would argue that the choice depends on where you’re coming from.

I want to address two different distributions that make sense for users coming from either MacOS or Windows. Those who are new to Linux probably don’t want to migrate to an operating system that looks nothing like what they are used to.

Ergo: elementary OS and Linux Mint. Let’s see which one is right for you.

elementary OS

I have a soft spot in my heart for elementary OS. In fact, I once called it my favorite distribution of all time. I used this distribution for years and found it to be an absolute delight. The elementary OS distribution offers a clean desktop that will be instantly familiar to those who are accustomed to MacOS. You’ll find a bottom dock and a top panel, and a desktop that has a very tasteful theme. All of those elements come together to make a Linux distribution that is not only easy to use but pleasing to the eye.

Also: Elementary OS 8 continues the tradition of a beautiful, user-friendly desktop

Based on the LTS release of Ubuntu, elementary OS benefits from the same reliability as found in its mothership, and it’s just as user-friendly (if not more so). You’ll find the default elementary OS theme to be classy and well thought out, making it very easy to interact with.

When you log into the desktop, you’ll find a dock and a top bar. On the dock, there are quick launchers for things like the file manager, web browser, to-do list, calendar, music player, video player, image viewer, app store, and a button to add new workspaces. 

On the top bar, there’s a desktop menu (at the far right), quick access to the calendar (center), and the system tray (far right).

No one, regardless of Linux experience, will have even the slightest problem with elementary OS, especially if you’re coming from MacOS.

One of the first things you’ll notice, upon opening the desktop menu, is that there’s very little in the way of preinstalled applications. That’s OK, because elementary OS has a great AppCenter for installing software.

elementary OS

Don’t fret if you see very few preinstalled apps in the desktop menu.

Jack Wallen/ZDNET

elementary OS also ups the ante on security with the addition of Secure Session, which enhances privacy and security by requiring a user’s consent in order for applications to access system features (such as cameras, mics, etc.). You can also set screen time limits, create custom keyboard shortcuts, and more.

Who is elementary for?

If you’ve been using MacOS and are looking to make the move (or at least test out) Linux, elemntary OS is the distribution for you. With a UI that is modeled after Apple’s, an app store that makes installing software easy, plenty of security, and ease of use, you’ll feel right at home.

elementary OS

The AppCenter makes installing software easy.

Jack Wallen/ZDNET

That doesn’t mean Windows users need not apply, as elementary OS is easy enough for anyone to use.

Also: The best Linux laptops of 2024 

elementary OS is an operating system that lives up to its name: in ease of use, it’s elementary, but that does not make it elementary in day-to-day functionality.

What is Linux Mint?

If you’re coming from Windows, there’s a Linux distribution right up your alley, and it’s called Linux Mint.

Linux Mint is often considered the single best distribution for new users. One of the reasons for this is that it sticks with a very traditional desktop layout. You’ll find a bottom panel, a desktop menu, a system tray, and desktop icons. And because Linux Mint is based on Ubuntu, you get the same package manager and stability.

Where elementary OS opts for a more modern look, Linux Mint might seem slightly outdated. Instead of leaning hard into aesthetics, Linux Mint opts for simplicity, and it does a great job of achieving that. Linux Mint is as easy to use as any operating system on the market.

Also: I tried the new Linux Mint 22.3 – it’s a masterclass in polish and quality-of-life fixes

While elementary OS opts to preinstall a bare minimum of software, Linux Mint delivers everything you need to get going, right out of the box. There are productivity tools (such as LibreOffice), multimedia viewers, chat apps, the ability to easily create web apps out of a website, and all the utilities you can think of. Once you’ve installed Linux Mint, you’re good to go.

And then there’s the system snapshots feature, which allows you to create restore points. Should something go wrong, you can roll back your desktop to a previously working state. This uses Time Shift, which I’ve covered in How to create system restore points on Linux with Timeshift – and why you should

Linux Mint

Time Shift simplifies creating system restore points.

Jack Wallen/ZDNET

As far as aesthetics, you get a theme app that allows you to select a theme, change the appearance, and pick a color. Or you can go to the advanced options and get a bit more granular with the look and feel.

Linux Mint

There are plenty of color palettes from which to choose.

Jack Wallen/ZDNET

Mint also offers a driver manager to make it easier to install the right drivers for your components.

Who is Linux Mint for?

If you’re looking for a turn-key Linux solution that you can install and is ready to go out of the box, and you’re coming from Windows, you’d be hard-pressed to find a better option than Linux Mint. No, it’s not nearly as beautiful as elementary OS, but it offers more features, has a larger community, and has a faster development cycle (which means you’ll get new releases and updates faster).

Which one is right for you?

This is simple: if you’re a MacOS user, go with elementary OS. If you’re a Windows user, go with Linux Mint. Either way, both distributions are outstanding and will serve you well for a very long time.

Also: The 6 Linux distros I expect to rule 2026 – and why

If either of these distributions interests you, download an ISO (elementary OS/Linux Mint) create a bootable USB drive, boot up, and install.

You won’t regret it.





Source link

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get our latest articles delivered straight to your inbox. No spam, we promise.

Recent Reviews


When you pick out a phone, you’re also picking out the operating system—that typically means Android or iOS. What if a phone didn’t follow those rules? What if it could run any OS you wanted? This is the story of the legendary HTC HD2.

Microsoft makes a mess with Windows Mobile

The HD2 arrives at an unfortunate time

windows mobile 6.5 Credit: Pocketnow

Officially, the HTC HD2 (HTC Leo) launched in November 2009 with Windows Mobile 6.5. Microsoft had already been working on Windows Phone for a few years at this point, and it was planned to be released in 2009. However, multiple delays forced Microsoft to release Windows Mobile 6.5 as a stopgap update to Windows Mobile 6.1.

Microsoft’s plan for mobile devices was a mess at this time. The HD2 didn’t launch in North America until March 2010—one month after Windows Phone 7 had been announced at Mobile World Congress. Originally, the HD2 was supposed to be upgraded to Windows Phone 7, but Microsoft later decided no Windows Mobile devices would get the new OS.

This left the HD2 stuck between a rock and a hard place. Launched as the final curtain was dropping on one OS, but too early to be upgraded to the next OS. Thankfully, HTC was not just any manufacturer, and the HD2 was not just any phone.

The HD2 was better than it had any right to be

HTC made a beast of a phone

HTC HD2 Credit: HTC

HTC was one of the best smartphone manufacturers of the late 2000s and 2010s. It manufactured the first Android phone, the first Google Pixel phone, and several of the most iconic smartphones of the last two decades. Much of the company’s reputation for premium, high-quality hardware stems from the HD2.

The HD2 was the first smartphone with a 4.3-inch touchscreen—considered huge at the time—and one of the first smartphones with a 1 GHz Qualcomm Snapdragon processor. That processor, along with 512GB of RAM, made the HD2 more future-proof than HTC probably ever intended. Phones would be launching with those same specs for the next couple of years.

For all intents and purposes, the HD2 was the most powerful phone on the market. It just so happened to run the most limiting mobile OS of the time. If the software situation could be improved, there was clearly tons of potential.

The phone that could do it all

Android, Windows Phone, Ubuntu, and more

The key to the HD2’s hackability was HTC’s open design philosophy. It had an easily unlockable bootloader, and it could boot operating systems from the NAND flash and SD cards.

First, the community took to righting a wrong and bringing Windows Phone 7 to the HD2. This was thanks to a custom bootloader called “MAGLDR”—Windows Phone 7.5 and 8 would eventually get ported, too. The floodgates had opened, and Windows Phone was the least of what this beast of a phone could do.

Android on the HTC HD2? No problem. Name a version of the OS, and the HD2 had a port of it: 2.2 Froyo, 2.3 Gingerbread, 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich, 4.1/2/3 Jelly Bean, 4.4 Kitkat, 5.0 Lollipop, 6.0 Marshmallow, 7.0 Nougat, and 8.1 Oreo. Yes, the HD2 was still getting ports seven years after it launched.

But why stop at Android? The HD2 was ripe for all sorts of Linux builds. Ubuntu—including Ubuntu Touch—, Debian, Firefox OS, and Nokia’s MeeGo were ported as well. The cool thing about the HD2 was that it could dual-boot OS’. You didn’t have to commit to just one system at a time. It was truly like having a PC in your pocket, and the tech community loved it.

Do a web search for “HTC HD2” now, and you’ll find many articles about the phone getting yet another port of an OS. It became a running joke that the HD2 would get new versions of Android before officially supported Android phones did. People called it “the phone that refuses to die,” but it was the community that kept it alive.

The last of its kind

“They don’t make ‘em like they used to”

HTC HD2 close up Credit: TechRepublic

The HTC HD2 was a phone from a very different time. It may have gotten more headlines, but there were plenty of other phones being heavily modded and unofficially upgraded back then. Unlockable bootloaders were much more common, and that created opportunities for enthusiasts.

I can attest to how different it was in the early years of the smartphone boom. My first smartphone was another HTC device, the DROID Eris from Verizon. I have fond memories of scouring the XDA-Developers forums for custom ROMs and installing the latest Kaos builds on a whim during college lectures. Sadly, it’s been many years since I attempted that level of customization.

It’s not all doom and gloom for modern smartphones, though. Long-term support has gotten considerably better than it was back in 2010. As mentioned, the HD2 never officially received Windows Phone 7, and it never got any other updates, either. My DROID Eris stopped getting updates a mere eight months after release.

Compare that to phones such as the Samsung Galaxy S26, Google Pixel 10, and iPhone 17, which will all be supported through 2032. You may not be able to dual-boot a completely different OS on these phones, but they won’t be dead in the water in less than a year. We will likely never see a phone like the HTC HD2 from a major manufacturer again.

HTC Droid Eris


A Love Letter to My First Smartphone, the HTC Droid Eris

No, not that DROID.



Source link