I clearly remember how happy I was when we finally got rid of the clacky keyboard that came with our original IBM PC clone in the early 90s and switched over to a quiet modern membrane keyboard. To me, this felt like the future, but then mechanical keyboards have made a massive comeback, and now carry the reputation that they’re simply better than the alternatives.
Well, they certainly aren’t the better option for me—someone who writes 10,000 words a day for a living. While mechanical keyboards are great for some things, I strongly prefer modern membrane keyboards, and there’s a good chance if you’re actually someone who writes for a living you might have a much better time if you leave mechanical keyboards behind.
Why mechanical keyboards never actually improved my writing
The promise that never delivered
I have plenty of friends and colleagues who are absolute mechanical keyboard diehards, who have been nagging at me for years to try one as my daily driver. I finally relented and found a good deal on a Keychron K8 Pro, which is a really nice keyboard for the price. Especially if, like me, you aren’t ready to go all-in on mechanical keyboards.
Well, it took me an entire year to get as fast and accurate on my shiny new mechanical keyboard compared to my Magic Keyboard, my Logitech chiclet-style keyboard, or the scissor switch keyboard on my M4 MacBook Pro. I really put in the time and tried to adapt to this thing, but even when I was writing with good flow, I didn’t enjoy writing on this keyboard. In fact, I’ve never enjoyed writing on any mechanical keyboard.
The first time I got to write on a chiclet-style keyboard with minimal travel, it changed my life. I found it comfortable, and I was able to instantly type with speed and accuracy. I found this even better for typing than on the desktop membrane keyboards of the time and that’s why I prefer to use something like the Apple Magic Keyboards for all my writing.
How low-profile scissor switches match the way I work
Fast, comfortable, and responsive
Of course, modern membrane keyboards also have some form of mechanical mechanism inside of them to control the motion and stability of the key. The built-in scissor-switch keyboard in my M4 MacBook Pro is quite possibly my favorite keyboard of all time so far. It has wonderful feedback while retaining that low-profile action I prefer. If Apple’s next Magic Keyboard acts and feels like the one in my MacBook, you can bet it’s going on my shopping list.
The myth of mechanical keyboards being “objectively better”
Don’t trust everything influencers tell you
To be 100% clear, mechanical keyboards absolutely have their advantages, benefits, and a legitimate reason to exist. I really enjoy playing PC games using my mechanical keyboard, and playing retro DOS games in particular is a treat. It was on a keyboard similar to this that I first played games like Jazz Jackrabbit and Commander Keen.
It’s a beautiful device, it’s satisfying to operate, I just would not want to do any real work on it. Typing on a mechanical keyboard, even the model I bought which is supposedly one of the quieter options on the market, is a source of constant annoyance to me. I bought my wife the same Keychron to replace her old mechanical keyboard, and it was a big improvement in noise level, but I can still hear her through the wall. I need noise-canceling headphones just to tolerate the keyboard in front of me.
I’ve tried various types of switches, and, of course, people will point out that the switches that are generally good for gaming aren’t going to be the best for typing, but honestly, the problem hasn’t mainly been how the switches operate, but just how much travel is involved in depressing a key,
I’m sticking with membrane and scissor switches for professional writing
For now, I’m setting aside my mechanical keyboard after giving it more than a fair shot. I’m going to keep using it as a gaming peripheral, especially as I dive into retro gaming on a CRT monitor, but as a serious tool to make a living? It just doesn’t match my feng shui.
That said, there are some interesting things happening in the world of keyboards. In particular, there are alternatives to mechanical keyboard switches such as optical, Hall effect, or TMR sensors to determine when a key has been depressed. Some of these technologies might allow for low profile keyboards that suit my taste while addressing some of the real shortcomings of membrane keyboards when it comes to durability, keypress registration, and limited repairability. Until then, I’ll just enjoy the silence as I get my work done in peace.

