Google already has a relatively small presence in my mobile life. Most of my favorite apps now come from F-Droid, and I long ago swapped out Gmail for Proton Mail. When I recently revisited LineageOS, I got a taste of just how far the open source alternatives to Google have come. Removing the tracking from your phone still comes with sacrifice, but not as much as you might think.
Grace any supported phone with Material 3 Expressive
Give your aging phone that Pixel vibe
For the unfamiliar, LineageOS may sound like an alternative to Android. Not so. The core Android operating system is free and open source, and LineageOS is an effort to make that source code usable on as many Android phones as possible—even after their official support periods have ended.
The LineageOS project doesn’t develop much of its own software. After all, it’s run by volunteers, and the bulk of their effort goes toward making sure the latest version of Android continues to run on each phone. Fortunately, that’s kind of all they need to do. Stock Android continues to get better.
Android’s current “Material 3 Expressive” design language won hearts and minds at the same time that Apple’s “Liquid Glass” pushed people away. With LineageOS, this interface is available on any compatible phone with the latest updates. As a result, my Moto Edge+ 2023 that I turned into a minimalist dumb phone feels as modern as my Google Pixel 10a. While there are aspects of the experience that are lacking, none of that has to do with how well software looks and runs. My phone feels buttery smooth and is still a treat to use this many years later.
7/10
- SoC
-
Google Tensor G4
- Display
-
6.3-inch Actua display
The Google Pixel 10a is a barely updated version of the Google Pixel 9a, with a slightly brighter screen and an upgrade from Gorilla Glass 3 to Gorilla Glass 7i. Google has shaved the remaining few millimeters from the camera bump, making it completely flat. Unlike prior versions of the Pixel a series, this model year does not share the same Tensor processor as the mainline Pixel 10.
Open source Android apps have gotten much, much better
Many of my favorite apps are now in F-Droid
If you’re looking to de-Google your smartphone and run an open source operating system like LineageOS, then F-Droid is the natural place to start. It’s an app store like Google Play, only all of the apps are open source, free to download, don’t contain ads, and respects your privacy.
For years, I liked the idea behind F-Droid, but I was frustrated by the quality of the options and the lack of variety. That has changed. There is now an open source app for most of the things I want to do on my phone, and these apps often look just as good as their commercial alternatives, if not better.
Open source app developers have really embraced Google’s new design language. Apps like the Lotus music player and the Easy Notes note-taking app look like they could have been developed by Google. My current phone, a Razr Fold, isn’t de-Googled—but I’ve downloaded Saber from F-Droid as my app of choice for writing by hand using my Moto Pen Ultra. I have ReFra installed as my preferred gallery app.
There are too many great options for me to list out here, so I’ll point you to some of the best open source Android apps my colleague has picked out as well as a look at some of my own personal recommendations.
Open Source photography is improving
It’s no longer Open Camera or bust
We call them smartphones, but the camera is arguably the most important part. Unfortunately, photo image quality has long taken a hit when switching to LineageOS. Most of the magic happens in processing, and that special sauce is often lost when switching away from the manufacturer’s stock software.
Fortunately, a growing number of stock camera apps are increasingly included or accessible on custom ROMs like LineageOS. On my Moto Edge+ I can choose between the Moto Camera and the default LineageOS one. This was similar to my experience running /e/ OS on the Murena Fairphone 6, where I could opt to use the Fairphone camera over the open source alternative.
- Brand
-
Murena
- Display
-
6.31 inches
The Murena Fairphone (Gen. 6) is the perfect option to bring together privacy and sustainability. Powered by the /e/OS operating system, the Fairphone (Gen. 6) protects you and your data at all times, while at the same time protecting the planet.
Even if you’re installing LineageOS because you want to exclusively use open source software, your options have improved. Thanks to PhotonCamera, I found my Fairphone could take photos comparable to my Pixel 10a.
Switching to LineageOS will still come with some pain
LineageOS isn’t to blame
Two opposing things can be true at the same time. On one hand, the quality of LineageOS and the open source apps you can run on it is better than it has ever been. It still feels like you’re running a modern phone, not a hacked together project.
On the other hand, my most recent attempt at de-Googling was the most infuriating I’ve had yet. That’s because over the past few years, RCS messaging has really taken hold here in the U.S. RCS has many nice features like typing indicators, reactions, and high-quality images. The problem? RCS is also only available via two apps: Google Message and iMessage. Only one of those is available for Android phones, and Google is in the name.
De-Googling means returning to an SMS texting app. From my experience, most one-on-one text messages continue to arrive, but I could no longer receive group messages. I didn’t know someone was sending a message, nor did senders know that I wasn’t receiving them. It was a complete disaster.
Other commonplace Android features are also tied to Google, such as Android Auto. Tap-to-pay options like Google Wallet and Samsung Wallet are also no longer available. Even the ability to share files between Android devices using Quick Share goes away.
De-Googling is viable, but can you deal with the cost?
I personally found that in order to switch to a de-Googled phone, it was easier to get a new SIM card with a new number than to try to free my existing number from Google. It’s RCS more than anything that makes the experience difficult for me. Of course, if your social circle is on WhatsApp, then this doesn’t really matter. It helps that there are open source apps available for everything from two-factor to offline navigation.
Ultimately, switching to the LineageOS and choosing not to install Google Play Services isn’t without pain, but you’ll still encounter far less friction than if you switch to a minimalist phone like a Light Phone 3 or an E Ink phone like the Bigme HiBreak Pro. Just go in with your eyes open and make sure to give the people in your life a heads-up.


