Ever since Linux distributions gained a cult following among computer users in the ’90s, they dreamed of overtaking Windows as the most widely used desktop OS. One company tried to do it by creating a distro that was as Windows-like as possible. This effort, Lindows, attracted the ire of Microsoft, but a trademark lawsuit almost backfired on the software giant.
What was Lindows?
Like “Windows,” but with an L (for “Linux”)
Lindows was a San Diego-based company founded in 2001 by MP3.com founder Michael Robertson. Lindows released its namesake Linux distribution the following year. As the name suggests, it was an attempt to create a user-friendly version of Linux that would appeal to Windows users, who made up the vast majority of the PC market. (A modern open-source descendant, Freespire, is a stand-in for Lindows in the above gallery; more on that later.)
Lindows’ user interface was not only inspired by the look and feel of the Windows 9.x experience via KDE, it also shipped with WINE. If you were going to appeal to mainstream Windows users, you had to run Windows software. The Debian-based distro also shipped with CNR, for “Click-N-Run,” an early version of what we would now call an app store. The then-new APT packaging system powered CNR.
With the buzz about Linux in the tech world, this was one of the first attempts to market Linux to mainstream computer users. Walmart even sold PCs preinstalled with Lindows on its online store. The YouTube Action Retro has Lindows in action.
The Lawsuit
Can you trademark “-indows?”
With a name that was close to the most widely-used desktop operating system, it’s not surprising that Lindows attracted a lawsuit from Microsoft because the company claimed that “Lindows” infringed its “Windows” trademark. This was roundly mocked in the tech press, including by PC Magazine columnist John C. Dvorak.
The lawsuit came on the heels of the US Justice Department’s antitrust actions against the company. There wasn’t a lot of sympathy for what even many non-lawyers regarded as a shaky claim, since “windows” was such a generic term, and Microsoft had used it in regard to user interfaces before marketing Microsoft Windows.
The Result
Microsoft buys the Lindows trademark, Lindows becomes “Linspire”
While Microsoft had successfully sued Lindows in other countries, a judge in the US denied Microsoft a preliminary injunction that would have halted the sale of Lindows. If a judge found that “Windows” was too obvious to trademark, this could have been a severe legal blow to the Microsoft empire.
This might have put pressure on Microsoft to settle with Lindows. Microsoft bought the trademark to the Lindows name from Lindows for $20 million.
What happened to Lindows?
Goodbye Lindows, Hello Linspire!
Since Lindows had sold its trademark to Microsoft, it couldn’t call itself, or its flagship product, “Lindows” anymore. Lindows became Linspire.
Linspire was a paid distro, in contrast to the free distros that most people who were interested in running Linux on the desktop were running such as Debian and the newly created Ubuntu in the mid-2000s. Linspire cost $50 to download from the company’s website and $60 for a boxed copy. That was just for the base copy. If you wanted to download software through CTR, you had to sign up for a paid subscription, either $20 per year for a “basic” plan, or $50 annually for a “gold” plan, though the basic plan was eventually made free.
This would have made Linspire a tough sell, since more home users were equipped with CD burners and broadband internet connections and could download and install their own Linux distros without the help of a vendor like Linspire.
While Linspire was a paid product, Linspire created a free version called Freespire. This mirrored the free/paid dichotomy of other Linux distros such as Fedora and Red Hat Enterprise OS or OpenSUSE and SUSE.
The rise of a friendlier Linux
People keep dreaming of usurping Windows with Linux
Other Linux distros, ones that didn’t charge for software updates, came onto the horizon. In the mid-2000s, the Linux community was buzzing about Ubuntu, another Debian-based system founded by a flamboyant tech executive, Mark Shuttleworth. Ubuntu captured the imagination of the Linux community through its good hardware support, polished user interface, and ease of installation compared to previous Linux distributions.
While Ubuntu would be a competitor to Linspire, as its developer Canonical was also eyeing the selling of paid support, Linspire decided to partner with Ubuntu instead, citing Ubuntu’s user interface and regular updates.
The idea of selling paid versions of Linux distros hasn’t gone away. While Red Hat and Canonical focus on the enterprise, Zorin OS, a distro that’s similarly pitched at people switching from Windows, also offers a premium paid “Pro” version.
Despite Lindows/Linspire’s quirks, it helped pave the way for the modern desktop Linux experience. CNR could be the direct forerunner to Ubuntu’s software store, or even Apple’s and Google Play’s app stores.
You can still buy Linspire, but only physical copies due to what its current developer, PC OpenSystems LLC, claims is a large number of credit card chargeback scams over the digital downloads. A free counterpart, Freespire, is also availabe for download.
Free or not, there are Linux users who still dream of unseating Windows.
Examining the legacy of Lindows
While Lindows/Linspire might have seemed quixotic, this effort paved the way for the modern desktop Linux landscape. While Linux can be daunting for newcomers, installing it is no longer the geek rite of passage that it was in the ’90s and 2000s. It’s a lot closer now to being something that normal people can use, and Lindows, however flawed its business plan might have been, was a part of that movement.


